• 01616 966 229
  • Request a callback
Stephensons Solicitors LLP Banner Image

Services
People
News and Events
Other
Blogs

Court of Protection considers life-sustaining treatment after crossbow suicide attempt

View profile for Sophie Atherton
  • Posted
  • Author
Court of Protection decides that man with irreversible stoma has the right to choose to die

In the recently published judgment St George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust v UJ & Ors [2026] EWCOP 39 (T3), the Court of Protection considered an application made by the Trust to authorise life-saving surgery which was opposed by the individual’s family.

Background

The application concerned ‘UJ’, a 45-year-old man who sustained a severe traumatic brain injury after attempting to end his own life by shooting himself in the head with a crossbow in April 2026.

UJ was taken to A&E and underwent emergency surgery to remove the arrow and insert an external ventricular drain to remove fluid from his brain. The fluid build-up was further managed by a lumbar drain and punctures until he was diagnosed with a large pulmonary embolism which required anticoagulation and meant that lumbar punctures were no longer clinically appropriate due to the risk of bleeding.

The Trust therefore proposed surgery to insert a shunt to manage the fluid on his brain in the long-term as, without further intervention, the fluid would continue to increase, negatively affect recovery, and likely be fatal.

It was accepted that UJ lacked capacity to make the decision himself and the official solicitor was appointed to act as his litigation friend. UJ’s mother and aunt were joined as parties, and other family members were also in attendance during the hearing and filed evidence.

Trust and family’s respective positions

There was no dispute about the clinical evidence, namely that UJ would decline into a low consciousness level or coma without the procedure. Clinicians explained however, that the prognosis spectrum for UJ’s recovery was wide and not possible to predict, ranging from living largely independently with some support to full nursing care in a hospital setting.

On conclusion of the evidence, the Trust maintained its application neutrally. It considered that the matter should be brought before the court, and it remained of the view that the procedure should be undertaken.

The family listened to the evidence carefully and expressed praise for the clinicians who cared for UJ but did not support the application on the basis that it didn’t align with UJ’s wishes, feelings, beliefs and values. Their position was that UJ valued his independence and had an adventurous spirit, and that he would consider being trapped in a body which cannot move or function independently “a living torment”. They felt that UJ’s actions were a tragic expression of the pain he was experiencing, and that whilst the prognosis spectrum was broad, even the best-case scenario would leave him deeply unhappy.

In a powerful statement by one family member, the court heard that:

“We cannot yet predict whether he will see, walk, talk or even have the capacity for basic human functions of feeding and toileting independently. But beyond this, my main concern is the mental load that will take its toll on UJ when, if ever, his condition allows him to become conscious enough to be aware of his state, and the immense pain and suffering that will cause him for the rest of his days. Let it be known, I understand that without the procedure, UJ will not pass away imminently… [and] will live, for an unknown amount of time. A burden that we, his immediate family, will happily take on as his carer; but he will live without the awareness of his condition. At peace that before the incident, he fulfilled his goal in life… fully independently, without apology”.

The court heard evidence that UJ had a history of poor mental health including depression and emotionally unstable personality disorder. He had made previous attempts on his life in 2023 and 2024, but later expressed that he was glad he hadn’t died and both times had called an ambulance. His family felt that this occasion was different – he meant the attempt to be fatal due to the manner, planning and fact that he wrote ‘DNR’ on his chest and arms beforehand. Tragically, his mother felt that if UJ didn’t want to live with all of his functions, she couldn’t foresee that he would want to live with disabilities.

On a fine balance and after hearing the evidence, the official solicitor herself supported the position of family in opposing the application.

Decision

The court was required to balance a number of factors including:

  • Clinical judgement that the shunt was the best opportunity for rehabilitation, albeit what his prospect of recovery would look like was unknown
  • The disability paradox – ‘in that sometimes those who one would not expect to be able to gain enjoyment out of life in such circumstances in fact do’
  • Family’s views as to what they felt UJ would want
  • The fact that UJ’s actual views were, and cannot be, known months after the incident
  • The different nature of his attempt compared to previously and the additional steps taken

Very sadly, the Trust’s application was refused on the basis that UJ would not support or want such a procedure.

This judgment illustrates the profound impact that the views of those close to ‘P’ can have when determining best interests, particularly in relation to serious medical treatment issues.

Whilst the Trust maintained its position that failure to carry out the procedure would likely be fatal to UJ, the court was persuaded by the evidence of his family that even the ‘best case scenario’ prospects of recovery wouldn’t align with his views around a meaningful quality of life and therefore it wasn’t in his best interests.

You can read the full judgment on BAILII here: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCOP/2026/39.html

Comments