Director, partnership & shareholder disputes

Running a business is rewarding but brings with it many challenges. Working in partnership with other directors, partners and shareholders allows you to grow your business more quickly, but what happens when there are disagreements between you?

We understand that things don’t always go to plan, and the burden of statutory responsibilities as well as the protection of the interests of the business and those running it can occasionally lead to dispute.

Looking for advice in connection with a director, partnership or shareholder dispute? Speak to a member of our team on 01616 966 229 and we’ll guide you through your next steps.

How our solicitors help

Our commercial litigation team has years’ of experience in sensitively handling and resolving in confidence director, partnership and shareholder disputes. Working closely with local businesses, we recognise early the issues that may arise and provide professional guidance, avoiding court wherever possible and keeping your business on track.

We always recommend that businesses put in place partnership or shareholders’ agreements wherever possible, which helps to resolve disputes much more quickly. However, whether or not you have signed agreements, our team will efficiently identify the problems with you, look at what you want to achieve and advise proactively as to your options.

Quick resolutions avoid business stalemate, and our team looks always to settle the dispute in a way which allows the parties to move forward.

Our commercial litigation team is supported by corporate and commercial practitioners, enabling Stephensons to deliver a full solution in handling your director, partnership or shareholder dispute where, for example, share transfers or sales are required to finalise a negotiation.

Need to put a partnership or shareholders’ agreement in place? Find out more.

Our services

Our specialists advise in disputes relating to:

  • Boardroom decisions
  • Strategy and structure
  • Value of goodwill in your business
  • Exit or retirement packages
  • Removing a director, partner or shareholder
  • Ending or dissolving the relationship
  • Disputes between shareholders

Our clients

Stephensons advises clients across the full spectrum of business models, including limited companies, partnerships and limited liability partnerships.

We have advised partnerships such as those within the legal, accountancy, medical, veterinary, dentistry, surveying and architectural sectors, and limited companies of a huge range from manufacturing to service, retail and leisure.

Case study

Our client was the majority shareholder in a successful company. A fellow director and shareholder had left the business and claimed to have been unfairly prejudiced by the remaining shareholder.

Our clients wanted to buy the exiting shareholder's shares, as there was investment in the business and the value was likely to increase.  Our team obtained favourable valuation evidence from an independent accountant which we used to successfully negotiate with the exiting shareholder. The shares were bought for a substantial discount and the company could continue with minimal disruption.

In some cases, where an immediate purchase of the shares can’t be made, our team will also advise on options that will allow a case to be concluded, such as deferred consideration. 

Shareholder dispute FAQs

How are shareholder disputes resolved?

A successful working relationship between business owners is paramount to a successful and profitable business. If this doesn’t exist or becomes lost, disagreements and a breakdown in communication can occur. If there has been a relationship breakdown this may require the professional help of a solicitor to allow the running of the business to get back on track. Shareholder disputes are, unfortunately, not an uncommon occurrence and usually happen when a minority shareholder is unhappy with how a majority shareholder is running the company, whether that’s general day to day management or a big decision for the company’s future, or when two equal shareholders cannot agree on the management of the business.   We pride ourselves on the ability to advise on shareholder disputes effectively by working closely with local businesses and often avoiding the intervention of the courts by efficiently identifying problems and resolutions with you.

Can shareholders overrule the board of directors?

This would depend on what is stated in the company’s articles, whether a shareholder’s agreement is in place and the numbers of shares held by the shareholders. If, as is usually the case, it states that the managing director has the final say when it comes to decisions and doesn’t state anything about the shareholders power to overrule a director’s decisions, then it isn’t very likely that they would be able to. However, with this being said, shareholders that hold at least 5% of the capital vote do have the power to call a meeting to discuss a different resolution. As well as this, most shareholders do actually have the power to appoint new directors to the board, so could do this in the hope that they will outvote existing board members and lastly, shareholders can take legal action if they feel that directors are acting unfairly or in breach of their director’s duties.

What is the most effective form of shareholder dispute resolution?

There are number of dispute resolution tactics that can be undertaken when resolving a shareholder dispute. Firstly, negotiation should be considered as this forces shareholders and/or directors to come face to face, explain their positions and come to a compromise. Failing this, mediation can also be considered – mediation is essentially a meeting between the disputing shareholders, but with an independent third party involved to help reach a fair agreement. Stephensons’ commercial litigation team are on hand to help reach a decision which works for everyone involved. Call our team to begin the dispute resolution process today.

What rights do I have as a minority shareholder?

Minority shareholders admittedly have less control than a majority shareholder, but that doesn’t mean that their rights should be compromised. As a minority shareholder, you will have the right to vote at annual shareholder meetings, to review information about the company and to vote on major corporate events such as appointing a new managing director. If, at any point, you feel that your rights as a minority shareholder have been ignored, you are within your rights to seek legal advice and may be able to take action. Call Stephensons today on 01616 966 229.

What type of director decisions require the approval of shareholders?

Types of director decisions that have to be run by the shareholders include:

  • Turning the business into a company
  • Selling off part of the company
  • Changing the compensation or benefits of managers

However the terms of any shareholder’s agreement would set out what decisions can be made by which parties.

Can the shareholder dismiss a director?

Not directly, no, but if the shareholder holds more than 5% of the company’s voting rights then they have the power to call a meeting with other shareholders and members of the board to discuss potential dismissal of a company director.

loading staff

4.7out of 10
4.7 score on Trustpilot Based on count 886

We're Great

It is our business to deliver legal services that work for our clients, and you can trust our specialists to take care of things on your behalf.

Our Trustpilot reviews

Ten tips for buying property at auction

Are you thinking about buying a property at auction? On the fall of the auctioneers hammer a buyer will then be under a legal obligation to buy the property 'warts and all'. A completion date is fixed at the auction and a buyer has to comply with...

Read more

Twitter commercial

@CommercialLLP

Charity of the Year donation - Macmillan Cancer Support

Over the last 12 months staff from across the firm have been fundraising for our Charity of the Year, Macmillan Cancer Support - through a variety of activities we are proud to announce that we have raised just under £8,000 for this...

Read more

Commercial reorder

  • Jonathan Chadwick
  • Louise Hebborn
  • David Baybut
  • Kate Bullen
  • Chris Graves
  • Alistair Gregory
  • Philip Richardson
  • Julie Ball
  • Martha McKinley
  • Paul Davies
  • Jonathon Waterhouse
  • Jessica Charnock​
  • Julie Hunter
  • Adam Pennington​​
  • Andrew Whitehead
  • Sebina Noreen Malik
  • Mark Williams​
  • Martin Haisley
  • Terri Meehan
  • Laurence Searle
  • Kenneth Tang
  • Neil Marshall
  • Declan Gilroy​
  • ​Kerrie Ainscough
  • Matthew Smith