• 0161 696 6170
  • Request a callback
Stephensons Solicitors LLP Banner Image

Defending claims of disability discrimination

A claim for discrimination arising from a disability can be brought when an individual is treated less favourably because of something arising out of their disability. This could include, for example, instances where customers have been denied a service because they cannot access it in the standard way that a person without a disability would.

A business or organisation may have a defence to such a claim if it can objectively justify their actions by demonstrating that their actions were proportionate (i.e. there is no reasonable alternative),and were taken in order to achieve a legitimate aim, (e.g. genuine health and safety reasons).

In order to utilise this defence, an employer has to show clear evidence that it had conducted a balancing exercise between it’s business needs and the discriminatory effect upon the individual and had given consideration to alternatives that might achieve the same result without being disadvantageous to the user.

 

Excellent4.6 score on Trustpilot
Rated 4.6 / 5 Based on 2045 reviews
Read all reviews

Defending a complaint or claim of discrimination arising from disability

Where a complaint or claim of Discrimination arising from Disability is received from a client/service user, the best way to attempt to defend it, is to first investigate and gather as much evidence as possible to establish whether the business had knowledge of the individual’s disability and whether the alleged conduct has occurred. This could include the gathering and consideration of CCTV footage, audio recordings, witness statements of staff involved and all equality and diversity policies and training records available.

What if the alleged discrimination didn’t take place?

If you find that the conduct alleged has not occurred then all evidence in support of this can be referred to in any response to the complaint or claim.

What if the alleged discriminatory conduct did take place?

If your investigation reveals that the acts complained of did take place, then you should undertake an immediate review of all preventative action which the business has taken to avoid service users being subjected to such treatment and whether a balancing exercise between the business’ needs and the detriment to the individual was undertaken in the particular circumstances. If it can be proven that adequate measures have been taken by the business to establish a defence on these bases, then there is potential for this to be accepted by a County Court. 

It is extremely important to seek specialist legal advice and assistance in dealing with complaints or claims of this nature to minimise the potentially costly consequences of a claim and the likelihood of proceedings escalating. Contact our discrimination law team on 0161 696 6170.

Defending disability discrimination claims - case study

We acted on behalf of a franchise owner of a well known retail and public service client.

Our client defended a claim brought by a service user who alleged that they had been discriminated against on the grounds of disability, during the Covid-19 pandemic. The service user alleged that they had been refused service due to their inability to wear a face mask.

The facts and basis of the service user’s allegations were largely disputed by our client.

We assisted our client in resolving the claim, out of court, bringing the case to a swift conclusion, keeping legal costs to a minimum and minimising the impact of the disputed claim, on our client and their business. 

  • Disability Discrimination In the Hospitality Sector - Guidance for Businesses

    Disability discrimination claims are one of the most commonly faced by businesses and organisations in the hospitality sector. Here specialist solicitor Rebecca Topping provides guidance for businesses, discussing their obligations under the Equality Act. Rebecca also provides a case example to highlight the importance that businesses meet their obligations.

    Rebecca explains what is meant by "making reasonable adjustments" and their importance in avoiding claims of discrimination.

  •  

loading staff

Bank holidays - what employers need to know

When it comes to bank holidays, the Working Time Regulations 1998 does not differentiate between them and any other days, meaning that they can lawfully be included in an employee’s 5.6-week minimum annual leave entitlement. Additionally, employees...

Read more

What Labour's victory in the polls means for UK employment law

In the run up to the general election, Labour made clear its plans to transform workers’ rights claiming that they were ‘not fit for the modern economy’. Their ‘new deal for working people’ made a pledge to implement sweeping...

Read more

Discrimination law staff reorder

  • Maria Chadwick
  • Rebecca Topping
  • Charlotte Brain
  • Abigail Martland
  • Kasey Hamer
  • Ambre Williams
  • Philip Richardson
  • Adam Pennington
  • Stephen Woodhouse
  • Terri Li