• 01616 966 229
  • Request a callback
Stephensons Solicitors LLP Banner Image

Services
People
News and Events
Other
Blogs

Why you should not rely on AI for legal advice - the risks of replacing legal expertise with artificial intelligence

View profile for Sarah Boustouller
  • Posted
  • Author
Can artificial intelligence replace my solicitor?

Artificial intelligence is becoming part of everyday life. From drafting documents and answering questions to summarising complex information, generative AI tools can produce detailed and convincing responses in seconds.

There is no doubt that AI has significant potential. The legal profession itself is increasingly using AI to support activities such as research, drafting and document review. However, there is an important difference between solicitors using appropriate AI tools alongside their professional expertise and safeguards, and an individual or business relying on a general-purpose AI tool instead of taking legal advice.

The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has highlighted risks associated with the misuse of AI in legal services, including inaccurate information and risks to client confidentiality.

So, what should individuals and businesses consider before turning to AI for legal help?

AI does not know your unique circumstances

One of the biggest problems with relying on AI for legal advice is that the quality of the response depends heavily on the information it has been given.

When someone instructs a solicitor, the initial information they provide is often only the starting point. A solicitor can ask further questions, identify gaps and establish the details and nuances that may make the individual's position different from another apparently similar case.

Someone using AI may instead provide a generic summary of their circumstances and receive a generic answer in return.

The problem is that specific facts can be critical to legal advice. A detail that appears insignificant to the person asking the question may materially affect the advice they would receive.

The same issue can arise when someone uses AI to prepare information before approaching a solicitor. While a summary can be helpful, relying upon an AI-generated account rather than explaining the circumstances fully could mean important details are omitted or given less prominence.

For a solicitor to provide appropriate advice, they need all the relevant facts and circumstances, not simply an AI-generated interpretation of them.

A document that looks professional is not necessarily fit for purpose

Generative AI can produce documents that look convincing. But a polished document is not necessarily one that properly protects the interests of the person using it.

We have encountered situations illustrating the potential consequences.

Scenario 1: A business sale agreement

A business had been sold, with significant funds paid initially and further payments due on a phased basis linked to performance.

A few months into the arrangement, the exiting director decided that he wanted to resign and no longer continue with the arrangement.

The document had been prepared using AI and did not contain sufficient protections to deal adequately with the circumstances that subsequently arose. Bespoke legal assistance was then required in relation to both the commercial dispute and employment aspects, as the director had also become an employee.

Had legal advice been obtained at the outset, an appropriately drafted commercial agreement could have incorporated protections addressing these issues, potentially saving considerable time and legal costs.

Scenario 2: A director buyout

In another situation involving two directors, one director was buying out the other.

A Share Purchase Agreement (SPA) had initially been prepared using AI. The exiting director subsequently obtained advice from a commercial lawyer and the SPA was redrafted with significant protections for the seller.

The purchasing director then instructed solicitors to review and redraft the SPA so that the protections within the agreement were more balanced.

Again, the AI-produced document had not provided an adequate solution. What began as an attempt to save legal costs ultimately resulted in legal assistance being required later in the transaction.

These examples demonstrate an important distinction. Generating a legal-looking document is not the same as receiving legal advice tailored to the transaction, its risks and the parties involved.

Beware of AI 'hallucinations'

Another important risk is something known as an AI hallucination.

This is particularly concerning in a legal context. A convincing answer could include an incorrect interpretation or even references that do not exist. AI-generated information is not always accurate. It can be misleading, incomplete or out of date and, on occasions, can produce information which is entirely fabricated.

AI can also produce responses which appear to support or reinforce the assumptions, views or preferred outcome expressed by the person asking the question, rather than providing balanced and impartial advice. This can create false reassurance or give an unrealistic impression of the strength of a person’s position or the likely outcome of their case.

This is not merely a theoretical concern. In August 2026, the SRA issued a warning notice specifically highlighting AI-generated hallucinations. It said AI tools can generate fictitious cases, references or apparently factual assertions that seem convincing despite having no basis in fact.

For someone without legal training, spotting a plausible but incorrect AI-generated legal answer can be particularly difficult.

Think carefully before putting confidential information into an AI tool

There is another risk which can easily be overlooked: what information are you giving the AI system in the first place?

To receive a detailed answer, someone may be tempted to paste extensive information about themselves, their business, another party, a dispute or even documents and correspondence into an AI tool.

That information could include commercially sensitive information, personal data or confidential information.

It should not be assumed that every AI service treats information in the same way. How information is processed and protected will depend upon the particular product, account, settings and contractual arrangements.

The SRA has specifically warned legal professionals about entering confidential client information into AI tools that lack appropriate safeguards, because of the risk of breaching confidentiality and wider data-protection requirements. The Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) also has dedicated guidance addressing how data-protection requirements apply to AI.

Clients should not upload confidential communications between themselves and their solicitor, including solicitor letters, emails or legal advice, to a public AI system.

Communications between a client and their solicitor may be protected by legal professional privilege. Sharing privileged material with a third party or uploading it to an external AI platform may risk that protection being lost.

Individuals and businesses should therefore think very carefully before entering personal, commercially sensitive or confidential information into a general-purpose AI system, particularly where they do not understand how the provider will process, retain, protect or potentially use that information.

Savings may end up costing more

Both of the scenarios above had something in common: AI was initially used in an attempt to save money on legal costs.

In each case, legal assistance ultimately became necessary.

Seeking advice after something has gone wrong can be considerably more complicated than obtaining appropriate advice and documentation at the outset. By that stage, parties may have acted in reliance on an agreement, money may have changed hands and positions may have become entrenched.

The initial saving therefore needs to be considered against the potential cost of correcting an inadequate document or resolving a problem later.

AI is a tool, it does not replace the need for tailored legal advice

AI will undoubtedly continue to change how people access information and how professional services are delivered. Used appropriately, it can be extremely useful.

But there is an important difference between using AI as a tool and relying on it as your legal adviser.

Legal advice involves more than producing an answer or generating a document. It requires understanding the individual circumstances, asking the right questions, identifying risks, applying professional judgement and tailoring the advice or documentation accordingly.

If an issue or transaction is important enough to require legal protection, relying solely on a generic AI response could ultimately prove considerably more costly than seeking the right advice at the outset.

Comments