Medical treatment consent - disputes & capacity

If there is any doubt as to whether a person is able to consent to medical treatment, for example due to a disability or vulnerability, then a mental capacity assessment must be undertaken before any treatment decision can be made.

If a person lacks capacity to make decisions about their medical treatment, a best interests meeting must be held with professionals and family members to try and agree on what is in the person’s best interests. The decisions must be specific to the actual medical treatment that is being proposed (for example surgery to investigate symptoms further, an amputation, hip replacement) and not a general decision that would cover any type of procedure or treatment.

Disputes about whether a certain medical treatment is in a person’s best interests may arise between family members and medical professionals and in the event of a dispute, an application can be made to the Court of Protection for the court to decide what is in their best interests. It is expected that the hospital that is proposing the treatment will make the application, but any party can bring such an application in the event of a dispute. The Court of Protection is also able to hear urgent cases where a treatment decision is required due to the circumstances of the case.

loading staff

Medical treatment disputes

Disputes in relation to medical treatment are very important decisions, as these decisions can have huge health consequences. Disputes can be about whether a person should have a particular medical treatment, challenges to end of life decisions and decisions to withdraw life sustaining treatment.

In the circumstances of a dispute or disagreement in relation to the provision of, continuation of or withdrawal of medical treatment, an application should be made to the Court of Protection to decide which course of action is in the individual’s best interests, before any action is taken.

It is extremely important that the correct processes and procedures are followed in these types of cases, as the decisions can have significant consequences. Decisions range from challenges to proposed medical treatment, to end of life decisions and decisions to withdraw life sustaining treatment. The court can also hear urgent cases where a decision is required in an emergency/urgent situation.

We have extensive knowledge and offer specialist legal services in this area, with our expert solicitors providing advice, guidance and representation through the process. We offer services nationally at competitive rates and legal aid is available subject to eligibility. For more information, call us on 0175 321 5096 or complete our online enquiry form and a member of the team will contact you.

9.3 out of 10
Trustpilot logo5-stars on trustpilot Based on count 551

We're Great

It is our business to deliver legal services that work for our clients, and you can trust our specialists to take care of things on your behalf.

Our Trustpilot reviews

Key figures at Stephensons Solicitors LLP include ‘tenacious’ associate Melanie Varey, who provides ‘clear advice’. 
Legal 500

Judge rules that it is in P's best interests to receive medical treatment despite submissions from an NHS trust

The case of University Hospitals Birmingham NHSFT v HB [2018] EWCOP 39 concerns an application made by the trust to rule out further treatment if a patient’s condition were to deteriorate. The protected party in this case is “P”, a...

Read more

Twitter block 1 tweet

SolicitorsLLP

Stephensons raises over £6000 for Derian House Hospice

The national law firm, Stephensons has marked the end of 12 months of fundraising for its Charity of the Year, Derian House Hospice. Over the course of 12 months, through a range of fundraising activities, the firm has raised more than £6,000 for the...

Read more

Mental capacity & Court of Protection reorder

  • Melanie Varey​
  • Sophia De Arez Cintra
  • Jamie Gordon
  • Sophie Maloney
  • Sarafina Nicolaou
  • Megan Taylor
  • Catherine Vaughan

We're always here for you

As an award-winning top 150 law firm, with over 450 staff based in offices across the country, you're never far from the advice you need.

Find your nearest Stephensons office and arrange a meeting

As an award-winning top 150 law firm, with over 450 staff based in offices across the country, you're never far from the advice you need.