The case of Nunn raised the question of the extent of any continuing duty of the police and the Crown prosecution service to assist him in gathering and examining evidence with a view to a further challenge to his conviction.
The ruling has wide implications on miscarriages of justice cases and the ability to obtain information post-conviction.
The issue is of such importance to fighting miscarriages of justice that it was supported by the following organisations: Innocence Network UK, Justice, The Criminal Appeal Lawyers Association (CALA)
The position following the ruling in the Supreme Court is that although the duty of disclosure post-conviction is not as broad as pre-conviction, the court accepted that if the convicted person appeals, disclosure should be made of any material which is relevant to an identified ground of appeal and which might assist the appellant.
It did state that the law did not impose a duty upon police forces holding archived investigation material to respond to every request for further enquiry which may be made of them. Material requested must be relevant to the safety of the conviction. In essence the court accepted the appellant's argument that disclosure must ordinarily be made of material if there is a real prospect that further enquiry will uncover something which may affect the safety of the conviction.
Correna Platt, Partner and criminal appeals solicitor
I suffered a miscarriage of justice due to police illegally withholding many witness evidence statements.
That evidence was amazingly given to the CPS prosecutor who used it to convict me due to my ignorant solicitor not objecting and asking for the hearing to be abandoned with that creating the MofJ.
I am looking for solicitors to sue my solicitors for their malpractice with not representing me properly.
Would you be able to do this ?
Regards, Mike.
Response from Stephensons
If you have been let down by the negligence of a solicitor in your personal or business life our specialist solicitor negligence team can help. Call us on 0161 696 6178 for advice or complete our online enquiry form and we will contact you directly.
For more information on our service please visit: Professional negligence claims against solicitors